$65 Refund Coming to Owners of Cars Towed During Snow Emergency

Lower Macungie Township Manager Bruce Fosselman reported on his investigation into the Jan. 3 snow emergency and the subsequent towing of vehicles parked along snow emergency routes at Thursday night's board of commissioners meeting.

Patch File Photo
Patch File Photo
Lower Macungie Township residents whose cars were towed during the recent snow emergency soon will be receiving a $65 refund check, Township Manager Bruce Fosselman told the Board of Commissioners during his report at Thursday night's meeting.

That money is being paid through a good faith concession from Mechanics Plus, the towing company that removed 26 vehicles from the township during the Jan. 3 snow emergency, Fosselman explained, although the township will be cutting the checks.

Mechanics Plus wants to continue working with the township in the future, Fosselman said, and therefore is willing to refund some of the money it charged that night, but it doesn't want to deal directly with the township residents whose cars were towed. 

"Mechanics Plus dealt with the residents the night the cars were towed, they dealt with the residents when the cars were picked up, now the owner wants to be done with the residents," Fosselman said.

Commissioner Jim Lanscek said that he didn't think the township should be involved with the refund process. "It looks bad that we are accepting money and getting it back to the people," he said.

Commissioner Brian Higgins told Lancsek he "completely disagreed" and said that in his opinion the board's involvement with the refund process would be a positive step.

"It shows we are responding to citizens who came to us with a problem," Higgins said, referring to the group of residents who came to the board's Jan. 6 meeting to express their concerns about the fees charged by Mechanics Plus. "As local government officials, we should have a better handle on who is charging what on our behalf."

In summarizing his investigation into the Jan. 3 snow emergency, Fosselman stressed two key points -- the township did nothing wrong and in this mind the fees charged by Mechanics Plus seemed higher than normal because they included both a towing charge and a winching charge.

He also reported the following to the commissioners:
  • Proper snow emergency signs exist in the streets where vehicles were towed in Clearview Manor and Shepherd Hills. 
  • Township staff declared the snow emergency by 3 p.m. on Thursday, Jan. 2., giving residents nine hours to move their cars. That snow emergency was announced via TV, radio, Facebook, Twitter, email and on the township's website. 
  • PA state law does not set a limit on fees that may be charged by a towing company but the township can enact an ordinance setting the price for towing services, which will be addressed by the Public Works Committee level in the future.
  • Township staff hopes to continue working on snow emergency procedures, including setting up meetings with the Public Works committee and Mechanics Plus and establishing additional notification procedures to let drivers know when a snow emergency is called. "I always think we can learn something," Fosselman said. 
MS January 17, 2014 at 07:27 AM
This is bad on the part of the township. If this business can stand to take that much money from customers and then say they want nothing to do with the refunds, (basically running away with their tails between their legs) then they should be dismissed from handling all towing services. Sometimes cheap isn't always better. Customer service is everything today. This is a disgrace
Michael D Siegel January 17, 2014 at 05:01 PM
so, they received some money back. Still an expensive mistake. They now know the township means business when a snow emergency is issued. No more BS. Bruce and Ben did a fine job. Kudos for the township staff. The streets were signed properly and many of the residents lied at the meeting which irritates me. Next time they will move their vehicles. Ancient Oaks West is waiting gentlemen for a learning curve as well
Tammy Merkel-Bauer January 22, 2014 at 09:16 PM
It's so petty ...Ben wants to enforce things at will instead we give him a salary and card blanc to be a price when he needs to flex his muscles


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »